7 Responses

  1. Ewan Smith
    Ewan Smith
    October 20, 2010 at 12:17 pm | | Reply


    I think the Madrid vs Milan game shows the growing gap between Italian football compared to Spain and England. Milan have spent money in the summer, but they have lots of older players they need to start replacing before they can make any advances in Europe. Milan’s older players have the experience and skill to perform on a regular basis every week in Serie A, and will probably be challenging for the league at the end of the season, but there is a lot of changes to be made before they can be the force in Europe they once were. As for my beloved Roma? Where do you start in your analysis? Every goal the conceded against Basel was a great goal, but every goal can be stopped. I don’t know how much Ranieri can do to strengthen the defence with the players he has, but I am worried for his position as manager.

    1. Robert
      October 20, 2010 at 3:29 pm | | Reply


      Ewan –

      I didn’t have a chance to watch the Roma match, so I didn’t want to dive too deeply into it.

      I also don’t know if I’d point out Madrid’s win as a definite sign of La Liga being better than Serie A. On this night (this night being last night) Madrid was definitely the better team. They were better prepared, better coached, and executed better. I don’t disagree that Milan looked old at times, but I would say wait until a few more rounds to see who’s still standing before we begin to say which is a better league this year.

      1. Rami S.
        Rami S.
        October 20, 2010 at 5:05 pm | | Reply


        I knew Milan would suffer before the match even started because they lack balance with aging components in midfield and defensively (Seedorf, Pirlo, Nesta, Zambrotta) while the management made the mistake of bringing in more forwards!

        Milan is getting closer to the original Los Galacticos era when Real bought attacking stars and won little. Milan need to get younger, solid defenders and at least one more midfielder.

  2. Rami S.
    Rami S.
    October 20, 2010 at 5:04 pm | | Reply


    Interesting comments which I’ve heard a lot in recent years but they are not very accurate. Last season, other than Barca and Real, the closest team was about 25 points away (I think Valencia in 3rd place). Italy’s league is more competitive. Check this piece I wrote for more details:

    http://www.serieaweekly.com/2010/10/italian-football-still-a-force-in-europe.html

    As for Milan, one must note a few clear things: the coach Allegri isn’t exactly a great one, the defensive line is cracking and aging (Zambrotta, Nesta), and the team lacks balance. The management signed Robinho and Ibrahimovic but instead should have brought just Ibra and signed a quality defender.

    This will give you a better idea on Milan:

    http://footballitaliano.co.uk/p6_66_4461_club-focus-milan-pato-scores-twice-on-return-as-robinho-gets-his-first-rossoneri-goal.html

  3. David H
    David H
    October 21, 2010 at 1:22 am | | Reply


    I’m not even sure there’s anyone at Roma who could fire Ranieri (not that I want that to happen.) Do the banks let Rosella make those decisions? Regardless, it would be foolish to let him go. You don’t become a bad coach overnight. He’s had an amazing amount of injuries, plus Burdisso not arriving until the trade deadline.

    As for Milan, I wouldn’t count out any team that has an in-form Pirlo. Surely Allegri knows it’s defense he needs to work on. Unless Silvio is holding him back, making him play all 4 together, Milan should be there ’til the end like they (almost) were last season.

    And who cares which is the stronger league? I don’t. I find Serie A & the Bundesliga to be highly entertaining, which is enough for me. If other people like the violent brutality of England, or the lopsided La Liga, good for them.

  4. Ewan Smith
    Ewan Smith
    October 21, 2010 at 11:05 am | | Reply


    The point I was making had nothing to do with the entertainment of the leagues because I find England, Spain and Italy entertaining in different ways and wouldn’t want to get into an argument about which is better because everyone has different interests in football and each league has it’s strengths and weaknesses. But in the modern game, with the tempo and skill that is required, Inter Milan seem like the only Italian team capable of doing anything in the Champions League and I strongly agree with the points Rami has made above.

  5. Ewan Smith
    Ewan Smith
    October 25, 2010 at 1:49 pm | | Reply


    http://www.footbo.com/News/717536347066750

Leave a Reply